Why You Keep Repeating the Same Painful Patterns and What Greek Myths Know About It

Episode 152

 

Written by Sarah Herstich, LCSW, a Certified EMDR Therapist, EMDRIA-Approved Consultant, and Somatic Experiencing Practitioner. Sarah hosts The Complex Trauma Podcast and owns Reclaim Therapy, a trauma-focused group practice in Horsham, PA.

If you keep ending up in the same painful patterns, nothing is wrong with you. For many people with complex trauma, repeating old relational dynamics is the nervous system reaching for what feels familiar, even when familiar hurts. In this post, I'm looking at trauma reenactment through the lens of Greek myth, inspired by my conversation with psychotherapist Dr. Gillian O'Shea Brown, and sharing why healing these loops usually has to happen in the body, too.

Key Takeaways

  • Trauma reenactment is the tendency to recreate painful relational dynamics from early life, often without realizing it.

  • What feels like intense chemistry can sometimes be your nervous system recognizing something it already knows.

  • Many of these patterns started as survival strategies that kept you connected to the people you depended on.

  • Understanding a pattern is an important start, and lasting change often requires new experiences in the body.

  • Patterns that formed in relationship often heal in relationship, slowly and with support.

You promised yourself you'd never end up here again. And then, somehow, there you are. It's a different person, maybe a different city or even a different decade, and it's the same sinking feeling in your stomach.

For a lot of people with complex trauma, this is one of the most painful parts. You can see the pattern. You can probably explain it better than most people could. And you still find yourself right back in it, wondering what is wrong with you.

I've been thinking about this a lot since my conversation with psychotherapist Dr. Gillian O'Shea Brown on The Complex Trauma Podcast. Gillian wrote a whole book, Psyche's Awakening, about how Greek myths map the patterns so many of us carry. And honestly, a guy pushing a boulder up a hill for all eternity has never felt so relatable.

This post is meant to help you understand your patterns with more compassion. It isn't a substitute for therapy or a way to diagnose yourself, and if something here stirs a lot up for you, please go gently and reach out for support.

What is trauma reenactment?

Trauma reenactment is the tendency to recreate, often without realizing it, relational dynamics that echo early painful experiences. In psychology, the older term for this is repetition compulsion. It can show up as being drawn to partners who feel emotionally unavailable, overgiving in friendships that never give back, or working for bosses who feel a lot like a critical parent.

five steps of the loop, from an early wound to a survival strategy, the familiar pull, the old pain returning, and shame, with “breaking the loop” in the center.

The loop of trauma reentactment

It's easy to read this as self-sabotage.

I see it differently.

These patterns usually started as survival strategies.

If love felt conditional growing up, part of you may still be trying to earn it. If a parent was hot and cold, part of you may still be waiting for the warm moment to come back and stay. Many clinicians describe this as an unconscious hope for a different ending, a chance to finally get what you needed the first time around.

Why does the wrong person feel like chemistry?

Here's the part that makes this so confusing. The pull toward a familiar pattern often feels really, really good at first. It can feel like butterflies, electricity, and that can't-eat, can't-sleep feeling all at once.

Your nervous system recognizes patterns long before your thinking brain catches up. When someone's way of relating matches what you grew up with, your body can light up with recognition. That activation (the racing heart, the stomach flips, the constant checking of your phone) can feel a lot like attraction. Sometimes it is attraction. And sometimes it's your system bracing for something it already knows.

Gillian put this so well in our conversation. When people map out their patterns, the "crazy chemistry" can start to look a lot more like stress hormones and an old story. That's a hard realization. It can also be a relieving one.

What can Sisyphus teach us about trauma loops?

In Greek myth, Sisyphus is punished by the gods to push a massive boulder up a hill, only to watch it roll back down, over and over, forever. Gillian uses his story to describe what she calls "the bite that fits the wound," the way new experiences keep pressing on the same old pain.

What strikes me about Sisyphus is how exhausting it is. Many of the people I work with have no shortage of effort. They're working incredibly hard. They read the books, they listen to the podcasts, they can explain their attachment patterns in impressive detail, and they still end up at the bottom of the hill again. When that happens, it usually means the pattern lives somewhere deeper than willpower can reach.

Where do these patterns start?

For many complex trauma survivors, the roots go back to early relationships with caregivers. Gillian connects this to Medea, one of the darkest figures in Greek myth, and to what she calls the primary parent wound.

In real life, that wound is rarely obvious. It can look like years of walking on eggshells. It can look like love that came with conditions, or a parent who was your source of comfort and your source of fear at the same time. A child in that position can't leave and can't make sense of it, so they adapt. They get small, or helpful, or perfect. Many decide the problem must be them.

Those adaptations made sense. They kept you connected to the people you depended on. The tricky part is that the same strategies that protected you as a kid can keep you circling the same hill as an adult.

Why isn't understanding the pattern enough?

This is the part I care about most as an EMDR therapist and Somatic Experiencing Practitioner. Insight matters. Being able to say "oh, I keep choosing people who feel like my dad" is a big deal. But a lot of us know the moment where we can name the pattern perfectly and still feel our body pull us toward it anyway.

These patterns live in your body as much as your mind. They show up as a tightening in your chest when someone takes too long to text back, or a strange sense of calm when someone is a little unavailable, because that's the kind of distance you learned to live with. Healing often means helping your nervous system have new experiences, in small doses, until something different starts to feel safe enough. In my experience, slow really is fast here.

How can you start stepping out of the loop?

There's no five-step fix for a pattern that took years to form, and I'd be suspicious of anyone who promises one. These are a few gentle places to begin.

Notice the pattern with curiosity

Gillian's book includes an exercise she calls the erotic emotional map, where you look at your relationships with your parents growing up and then at the people you've been drawn to as an adult, and notice the echoes. She's offering the chapter and a mini course for free on her website, which I've linked below. You don't need a formal exercise to start, though. Simply noticing "oh, this feels familiar" is a real beginning.

Check in with your body

The next time you feel that magnetic pull toward someone, pause for a breath. Where do you feel it? Does it feel like warmth and ease, or more like bracing? There's no right answer. You're just gathering information about what your nervous system recognizes.

Go slowly, and get support

Patterns that formed in relationship often heal in relationship. Working with a trauma-informed therapist, especially one trained in approaches like EMDR or somatic therapy, can give you a safe enough place to feel what's underneath the loop without getting swept back into it.

How do you find a therapist who understands trauma patterns?

Look for someone who specializes in complex trauma or relational trauma and who works with the body as well as the mind.

Approaches like EMDR, Somatic Experiencing, and parts work can all help with patterns that insight alone hasn't shifted. It's also okay to ask a potential therapist how they think about repeating relationship patterns and see whether their answer feels shaming or curious.

If you're in Pennsylvania or Florida, my team at Reclaim Therapy works with exactly this. You can reach out for a consultation here.

In my episode with Dr. Gillian O'Shea Brown, she tells the stories of Sisyphus, Medea, Medusa, and Chiron, and what each one reveals about complex trauma. She is such a good storyteller, and I think you'll hear yourself somewhere in there. Listen to the full episode here, and grab Gillian's free chapter and mini course on the erotic emotional map at her website.

Content note: the episode includes a discussion of sexual assault in Medusa's story.

Have a question you'd love me to answer on the podcast? Send it my way. And if you want something to help your nervous system in the harder moments, my free Dysregulation Toolkit is there for you.

If you've rolled that boulder up the hill more times than you can count, I want you to know that the rolling itself shows how hard you've been trying. You learned these patterns for good reasons, and you can learn new ones too.

It takes time, it gets messy, and it's possible. 🧡


Frequently Asked Questions

Is repeating unhealthy relationship patterns a trauma response?

It can be. For many people with complex trauma or CPTSD, repeating familiar relational dynamics is one way the nervous system seeks out what it knows. It isn't the only explanation, and a therapist can help you sort out what's going on for you.

What is the difference between trauma reenactment and self-sabotage?

Self-sabotage suggests you're working against yourself. Trauma reenactment frames the same behavior as a survival strategy that once protected you and hasn't yet caught up to your present life. Many trauma therapists find the second framing more accurate and a lot less shaming.

What does "the bite that fits the wound" mean?

It's a phrase psychotherapist Dr. Gillian O'Shea Brown uses for new experiences that land right on old pain and reactivate it. She connects it to the myth of Sisyphus, who is forced to push the same boulder up the same hill forever.

What is the primary parent wound?

Dr. Gillian O'Shea Brown uses this term for the pain that comes from depending on a caregiver for love and safety while that same caregiver is also a source of fear, criticism, or unpredictability. It often shows up in adulthood as shame, difficulty trusting, and survival strategies like people pleasing or hyperindependence.

Why do so many trauma survivors relate to Medusa?

In older versions of the myth, Medusa is assaulted, then blamed and punished for what happened to her. Many survivors see their own experience in that story, especially the experience of being treated as the problem after speaking up about harm.

Can you break a trauma pattern?

Many people do. It usually happens gradually, through awareness, support, and new experiences that help your nervous system learn that something different can be safe. Healing is rarely linear, and slipping back into an old pattern doesn't erase the progress you've made.


If you love tuning in to the podcast, please take a second to leave a review! It truly helps other people find the show.

 
Next
Next

Parts vs Alters (How to Tell Everyday Parts From OSDD and DID)